Why We Need To Talk About The Insane YouTube Kids Problem… #Elsagate

‘Sup, beautiful bastards, I hope you’re having a fantastic Friday! For today’s Friday show, I want to talk about a heavily requested, and I think important, story. It’s around the situation that you may have heard of as “Elsa Gate.” As of late, there’s been a lot of concern around YouTube’s children-focused content. Some children’s videos, I would argue MOST children’s videos, are completely normal content, like nursery rhymes, color, and counting. But there’s also a huge subsection of videos that are very troubling. And the range here is, “Okay, that’s kind of weird and kind of inappropriate.” to “What the fuck!? How is this in YouTube Kids?!” Now, what we often see is that they use children’s characters in the videos. They have video titles, tags, that are specifically designed to take advantage of the YouTube algorithm. Essentially, the way it works is on YouTube Kids, you get longer viewing time. Unlike an adult that’s specifically searching, and hopping from video to video, When you have a kid, often like an iPad is being put in front of them, And a lot of the kids just watch video after video as they pop up on the screen. Which is where these videos can take advantage of the algorithm. Kid’s watching silly fun videos about Minions, Despicable Me, and then this ridiculous insanity pops up from that. This is from “Zinzin Cartoon,” titled “Minions Banana Baby Drinks Piss Water Funny Story Full Episodes! Finger Family song Nursery Rhymes.” Also, you notice a lot of the titles, the descriptions, the tags, is kind of like this word soup. Once again, that’s people taking advantage of the algorithm by using highly searched terms in their description. There’s a full disgusting rainbow of obscene and really inappropriate videos. There’s a lot of tricking people into drinking pee, eating poop, you get stuff like “Princess Rapunzel and Spider Man Buried Alive: Venom Poop,” and you see what looks to be a bloodied Rapunzel with poop on her head. Also, if you’re wondering why this is called “Elsa Gate,” but I haven’t even mentioned Elsa yet, It’s because I want you to know that this is much more than just a character from Frozen being in some weird video. A lot of the original weird disturbing videos included someone either playing Elsa, or an animation of Elsa. Frozen, of course, was one of the most popular pieces of children’s entertainment in an incredibly long time. Frozen, the specific characters, the names of the songs – constantly searched. A lot of weird videos started with her, then people start including more characters like Spider Man, Hulk, Joker, or honestly any character you can imagine, there is probably a weird video like this out there. They had this video of Elsa, apparently sick, and Anna is trying to take care of her, so then they check her temperature rectally. Also, then Anna kisses Elsa. That video has 7.8 million views, and it is not even close to being their biggest! That same channel has another video with 20 million views, Once again, this is a kid’s channel and video. All the characters are drinking at a dance party, and it ends up with the characters waking up in bed together, naked, partially clothed. Also, keep in mind, it’s not just animation channels. Got to give a shout-out to the channel called Pranks Game. They actually feature live actors, and what really just feels like softcore porn. In this video, “Spiderman Vs. Black Cat Girl,” starts off with this woman beating the shit out of Spiderman in bed. Spider Man then proceeds to stare at her chest; he then grabs her breasts, causing Black Cat to bite her lip, and changes her mount position, continues to beat the shit out of Spiderman, and then she has a dance party. Then, Spiderman fights back, he gets on top of her. Black Cat fights back, she kicks him in the dick three times – 5.8 million views. That’s not even going into their superhero love story, where eventually Spiderman and Black Cat, I dunno, it looks like they fuck on a couch? That’s got 8.7 million views. And keep in mind once again that all of these tags everything It’s geared towards kids. The channel “Toy Scouter” is another fantastic weird example We’ve done a masterful job of taking advantage of the algorithm past 30 days They’ve gained over six hundred sixteen thousand subscribers if nine point seven million subscribers on the champion videos like this world everyone loves spider-man with frozen elsa minnie Spider-girl peppa pig and joker in real life obviously you see there They’re taking advantage of the tags nineteen point five seven million views Six hundred eighty seven comments most people would look at those numbers and go oh that person’s boosted Oh probably not We’re talking about kids that aren’t participating in the comments section watching this video this video by the way, it’s hard Do you explain what happens everyone’s happy and then uh? Oh i’m to go worldstar nelson and spider-man’s essentially naked and rapunzel gets Chloroformed by joker and kid ninh and chase. Yes. I watch paw Patrol. I have children He gets stabbed in the ass with a needle and ruble once again. I told you I watched paw patrol He captures and then seemingly is trying to murder a minion Oh and a dinosaur any abducts Peppa the pig some of the other videos. I blow up on this channel I just love the thumbnail Princess Rapunzel versus nails through finger Oh, my god, Princess Rapunzel got nailed through the foot spider-man sharp nails on toilet Fuck is wrong with people Also, some channels aren’t even trying to hide it super hermes TV has a video call hall patrol babies pretend to die suicide There’s a little clip from that beauty In response to most of this especially as it’s gained more and more traction in the new as has been what the fog how can There be monetization issues things people are calling the ad pocalypse when this is out there Getting millions of you a lot of people saying that we’re getting ads while watching these videos in response to these kinds of videos YouTube Has put into place new policies in Jilin when they issued new monetization policies that included content that depicts family-friendly characters engaged in violent sexual violent behavior even if done for comedic or satirical Purposes is not eligible for monetization, Malik Ducard the head of YouTube’s family and learning content said that the videos were a quote Extreme needle in the haystack but of course people’s response to that was how is this a needle in a haystack situation when you’re talking about tens and sometimes Hundreds hundreds of millions of views were people reporting that these videos were prominently featured on the YouTube kids app that was an app that Acknowledged that there was really messed-up content on YouTube and then said hey we’re going to make sure the content is safe But because the content isn’t initially looked at by human beings you know obviously the algorithm rules all on YouTube these videos were getting through And most importantly they were getting through to children But despite the changes if you still search for certain terms you find inappropriate video We’re seeing in general is that the videos have continued despite having to fight demonetization This isn’t great for YouTube because a lot of the mainstream outlets have been covering a New York Times putting out a piece on this earlier this month writing on YouTube kids Startling videos slip past filters as opposed by James Bridle that blew up on media saying these videos wherever they are may ever they come To be me whatever they’re conscious intentions ie to accumulate ad revenue feeding upon a system Which was consciously intended to show videos to children for profit unconsciously generated emergent outcomes of that are all over the place We’re talking about is very young children effectively from birth being deliberately targeted with content, which will traumatize and disturb them via networks Which are extremely vulnerable to exactly this form of abuse, And he was arguing that YouTube was causing infrastructural violence against children so after this popped up in the news again YouTube decided to respond again. Juniper Downs, YouTube’s director of policy saying We’re in the process of implementing a new policy that age restricts this content in the YouTube main app when flat adding age restricted content Is automatically not allowed in YouTube kids So how will this work the first line of defense is the algorithm right and so based on how YouTube’s algorithms have treated you your faith in this might be mixed and afterwards people like yourself if you see these videos flag them as an appropriate, a human will then Look at that video determine if it’s flagged properly YouTube says they have thousands of member Across the world to help if it’s in the wrong the video will be flagged and will become age restricted, then if the video Becomes aid restricted it won’t be in the kids app, now will all of that work Maybe I think if there was ever a fire that could get YouTube off its ass to do something. It’s a oh my god We’re showing horrible shit to children fire. I will say overall so far does seem like the most horrid examples We’ve found I’ve been taken off the kids however looking into it it seems that companies issuing Takedowns have been more effective than YouTube’s system It’s because many of the horrendous videos have been taken down due to copyright claims and not because of age gate But ultimately the big problem of hoping people flag these videos is there there is a reason that these videos got so many millions of view under so many people’s radar adults aren’t searching for this stuff they’re searching for like a Regular normal daddy finger song and they plop that iPad in front of a kid and then 20 minutes later Thanks to the algorithm Weird shit shows up so unless people continue to be proactive which is not going to be the case long term this problem could still Very easily continue and grow and so while I think we can all make a temporary push to look for a lot of this weird Content flag it see what YouTube does I would say is to my fellow parents out there also to the brothers the sisters Anyone who is his is responsible for a child So I’ll try to take that extra minute to make sure we know exactly what our children are consuming online. I’m not trying to shame you I think most people that downloaded the app were like, “okay YouTube made it safe for my kids,” but ultimately like all things with your children It all comes back to you are responsible You got to look out and now that maybe you watch this video or someone forwarded this video to you You know that there is an issue. That’s without even jumping in to all the child exploitation We’ll save that for another day of course because this is the Philip DeFranco show I want to know your thoughts on this story also What do you think YouTube could do better in situations like or are you thinking? You know YouTube’s doing their best. It’s on the pair or a mishmash I’d love to know your thoughts see that’s why I’m going to end today’s show also remember if you like this video you like what? I’m trying to do on this channel you want to support Independent media be sure to go to DeFrancoElite.com, sign up become a member of the nation. Also, if you missed yesterday’s Philip DeFranco Show, you want to catch up: Click or tap right there to watch that. If you want to watch the newest behind-the-scenes vlog, click or tap right there to watch that.
So that’s it. Of course, as always, my name’s Philip DeFranco; you’ve just been Phill’d in; I love yo faces, and I’ll see you next time.

, , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Post navigation

100 thoughts on “Why We Need To Talk About The Insane YouTube Kids Problem… #Elsagate

  1. THANK YOU for covering this! People sit their kids in a corner with their tablet and at a glance it looks innocent but because it's YouTube kids, our kids are exposed to this! This problem IS STILL prevalent! Now they're using the algorithm in other languages, so you can't even read the title of the video and they're popping up all over the place!

  2. I've been watching youtube since I was 4, and I'm 12 thank god I watched people like: "Nerdcubed", "Jacksepticeye", "DanTDM", "Deadlox", "Skydoesminecraft (Or today "Netnobody")"

    Edit: And smosh also you might say that I have bad parents please go away swearing is just words and I never repeated it.

  3. A couple years ago when my brother was 4 he was watching YouTube and didn’t know how to read so he would pick videos by their thumbnails and one time I sat next to him on my phone and looked over to what he was watching and it looked weird it had Spider-Man and cat woman in it so I grabbed his phone and looked at the title it said something about Spider-Man and cat woman and said SEX TAPE if course he wasn’t in trouble cus he couldn’t read. I’m so glad YouTube made it safer for kids 🙄

  4. Why is it only up to the algorithm you would think content for kids would require an actual team of humans monitoring the content

  5. This just happened with my 7 yr old daughter. I walked by her and it caught my attention so I stopped and watched.. it was women dressed up as princesses singing about sexual things while motioning sexual things. I was so confused when I saw it. I asked her how is this on.. she said she typed in Disney princesses. Super disturbing people do this.

  6. pedophilia has forever scared me. me and my sibling were swimming and my mom took pictures for facebook. i told her not to post them but she didn't understand. nothing happened when i searched myself up but i make sure my sibling doesn't watch these videos since pedophilia and child harm makes me anxious.

  7. There is a lot of stuff like this on the net! Don't let your young kids anywhere near the net without checking on what they are looking at!

  8. I accidentally found out about elsagate while watching random youtube rants. I am scarred for life. Can't imagine what it does to kids to see this shit.

  9. 4:15 That's just out right disturbing. Even as an adult. Imagine kids watching that. Explains why kids these days have such a fug up mind.

  10. Was using this video in a conversation about the new ones surfacing. Its horrible they are getting more clear waiting till halfway though a video or starting at a random time once we as parents decide a video is trustworthy. Not only depicting suicide and sexual things and violence but I've heard about is a song that suddenly starts singing about how you should go turn your oven on when your parents are sleeping and leave it. Awful this is still being found on YouTube kids.

  11. I watch ASMR videos. I was sickened to see a toddler being filmed by her Mother creating an ASMR video. I feel it is wrong.

  12. My parents closely watched what i played/viewed. They knew that i would one day find content that im not supposed to and they made sure that i knew that its not what im supposed to do/how im supposed to act. So when i did find innapropriate stuff i just clicked away and kept it moving. Nowadays i see so many people giving their kids a tablet and not watching them.

  13. I have seen some of these now that i think of it but i always turn them off. It makes me so angry. The thing is you flag them and more are going to come back up, we need to get more proactive.

    Exactly what's been said. If you can't know what your kids arw watching. Delete the app.

  14. This is exactly why my children haven’t been able to watch YouTube in several years!! This is absolutely absurd and I could kick all these bastards in the nutt sac.

  15. If I ever get kids,
    Video games, sure, maybe
    TV, yeah, maybe, why not

    But my kids won't get their own PC or phones until 10,12, or 14 unless I'm seeing what they're watching.

  16. Whenever something like this comes up people who don't have kids are suddenly experts on how to be a parent. I think that people really need to stop making such a fuss. When I was 5 I watched Arnold Schwartzinger pull his eye out in the sink in the move Terminator. I thought thought it was funny and asked my sister to rewind it several times. I turned out fine. People really need to stop wrapping kids up in cotton wool. Nothing terrible is going to happen to them if they stumble upon a video of Spiderman grabbing cat woman's boobs. My 6 year old self probably would have found it hilarious. For those who say that kids should be outside, well there are packs of stray dogs in my neighborhood. There are also brown ticks everywhere that carry diseases and there is a large road with heavy traffic. I was once outside playing as a kid and a man tried to get me to go off with him. Playing outside unsupervised isn't exactly safe in many environments.

  17. I think there might be some sort of fetish or they have a love for needles because I see this in almost every video my little sister watches, it's a little ridiculous

  18. Most people who make these videos are usually pedophiles… my little cousin used to watch vids like this…
    People like this have their channel took down.

  19. I had too watch someone’s kid at a party and I did not do that and I come back and see what she is watching and I see Mickey Mouse cutting an ear ;-; I was like WHAT THE FU- I toke her iPad and changed it to a real no Momo popping up peppa pig vid and made her watch that,then I left again and then she clicked on a vid of Momo saying…..Momo Momo Momo is gonna kill you, I said out loud soo scared WHAT THE FUC-! AHH!!! Everyone got soo scared, and then I deleted YouTube kids and searched up daddy finger and it was normal,then I toke her iPad and just made her wheez for 80 minutes lmao

  20. Here's the thing. Put a block on YouTube on your Kids' Devices in your Router's settings. That way, They can't watch YouTube at all and in turn prevent them from watching that Fecal matter

  21. Was looking for a vid to show my daughter to back up what i try to teach her about youtube. Then, I bump into THIS idiot dropping F bombs! Guess I won't be using THIS vid for educational purposes! MORON!!!!

  22. I think that uncensoring soft gay porn on YouTube would be way more family finger… Oh shit I meant family friendly.

  23. (in the tune of Bingo)
    Don't be brutal,
    vulgar, obscene
    or else you could be banned-o.
    And thankfully, I'm not-o.

  24. Phew I'm Not The Only One That Likes Paw Patrol…


  25. What about kids who actually do YouTube videos? This topic is a major issue as well, but I'm shocked at these children doing videos wearing adult clothing and themes like nails makeup bfs gfs being 18 for a day etc. Why are parents exploiting their children? Comments are always disabled as well. Perverts out there watch these kids. And other children being influenced poorly.. these videos are horrifying.

  26. Youtube should absolutely be taking down these videos, but the best thing for parents to do is to simply create a playlist for their toddler or child to watch on repeat, where the parents themselves go through Youtube Kids and find appropriate videos that are child friendly and not this… borderline fetish porn disguised as kid content.

  27. Needle in a haystack? Don't you mean literal needles? Because a lot seem to love the use of syringes

  28. 4:10 reminds me of Hoops and Yoyo
    Also I've seen an ad about "gli Incredibli 2" (the elsagate one) It showed dash and violet scared in a cemetery

  29. Phil is such a hero for watching and summarizing these videos, they'll probably be in his recommended for a while

  30. I'm just getting more reason's to buy out Google and YouTube I can run them better then those morons called their staff.

  31. I used to watch courage the cowardly dog
    Ed Edd eddy
    Jonny bravo
    No YouTube just Cartoon Network
    Good old days

  32. bruh my kid's gonna be watching the quality content 👌 if I ever have one. I'm talking epic gaming and commentary content 😳😳😎😎

  33. These videos on Youtube are so rotten, it makes Ren & Stimpy Adult Party Cartoon look beautiful by comparison!

  34. Dude. These videos are a nuisance to parents and a nightmare to kids, they must be wiped off the face of the interweb.

  35. 4:09-I would do that to my Mom when I am a little kid, throw a ball at her head, and send her car on a collision course on the road and send it crashing into a streetlight.

  36. The videos Toy Scouter creates are pure nonsense, violence, and madness. I think Toy Scouter should be terminated.

  37. “then chase, yes i watch paw patrol i have children” that killed me and idk why
    edit: “them rubble, once again i told you i watch paw patrol!” killed me even more

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *